Why Apple Trade-In Usually Pays Less Than Cash

When you think about trading in, you think about Apple first thing, but what you don’t know is that Apple makes trade-in sound like the easiest way to get value from your old iPhone.
The truth is, Apple’s trade-in program has restrictions and lower payouts and sometimes even rejects phones that could still bring in solid cash.
At iMobile Repair Center in Detroit, we give you a clear, same-day alternative: cash offers based on real resale value.
Apple Trade In Restrictions (Aftermarket Parts, Must Power On)
Not every iPhone qualifies for Apple’s trade-in program. Here’s what usually gets rejected:
- Aftermarket parts like screens, batteries, or back glass.
- Cracked displays or water-damaged devices.
- Phones that won’t power on.
If your iPhone has been repaired outside of Apple, there’s a good chance Apple won’t accept it at all.
Typical Apple Trade In Payouts vs Cash Offers
Apple’s trade-in values are lower than what you’d get selling for cash. For example:
- An iPhone 13 might bring about $200 at Apple, but could be worth $300–$350 in cash locally.
- Pro models and higher storage versions see an even bigger gap
At iMobile Repair Center, we base our offers on real eBay sold listings and pay about 50% of the market value in cash instantly. No gift cards, no waiting.
When to Use Apple Trade In vs Cash
There are times when Apple trade-in makes sense, like if your phone is in near-perfect condition and you’re already buying a new iPhone at the Apple Store.
But if your device has aftermarket repairs, cosmetic damage, or you just want fast money, cash buyback is the better option. No restrictions, no hidden rules.
Why Instant Cash Is Faster & Easier
Selling for cash is simple:
- No rejection for aftermarket parts.
- No requirement to buy a new phone.
- Same-day payout in minutes.
Bring your iPhone to iMobile Repair Center in Detroit and walk out with cash today.